There Is No Antimemetics Division by "qntm" aka Sam Hughes. Meh. Recommended by E, who was apparently greatly enyoying it. I read about half way, around page 100 - one good thing, it is not a doorstep - but stopped. It had run out of appeal, and likely of ideas.The idea is that a class of "anti-memetics" exist; devices or entities that, unlike memes which spread themselves, instead cloak themselves. People forget they have seen the things, computer records degrade, paper records decay, and so on. The immeadiate problem is that while it is possible to imagine such a mechanism in human storage memory, which is mediated by consciousness and still rather mysterious, it is rather hard to see anything similar operating on computers, and impossible on paper, without a rather large suspension of disbelief.
The next problem is that's kinda the only idea the author has, and seeing the same idea played out across three-I-think-it-was stories I was getting rather bored.
Goodreads has those who love it and those less enamoured; of the latter variety all agree that the second half is worse so I feel justified in giving up.
No comments:
Post a Comment