Tis another Marple, though she is terribly discrete and slides in gently at the end in her little old lady knitting guise. I was going to be all offended because I guessed wrong, but in the end I think that while she cheated a bit, overall the answer is clear enough that I should have guessed right.So, my guess was Megan, based on the rather obvious I-hate-the-world stuff; the surprise factor; her not being included in the lists that Our Narrator makes; and her surprise return home on the morning of Agnes' call.
That return is only cleanly explicable in that she hears Agnes' call, and realises that Agnes knows something; that Agnes has seen something or - as I guessed correctly - has actually seen nothing, which is puzzling. With the true villain unmasked, her return has no explanation; which is why I say this is cheating a bit. I do agree thought that Mr S has a better motive than Megan.
Once you realise that Mrs S has been killed, then one realises that the letters are all a sideshow. I did so realise; in particular, the scrawled "I can't go on" is just not plausible as a suicide note: far too brief, and anyway doesn't even fit: she's only just that day got one letter. No-one even says these obvious things which is a clear sign of their importance. The replacement of "Barton" by "Burton" on one envelope shows they were all prepared in advance, but that doesn't get you anywhere.
Is killing Agnes believeable? Not really. As ever it is always the second murder that does the villain in; and in this case the realisation that she hasn't seen anyone, whilst puzzling, isn't really going to go far; the risk of a murder is obviously higher and cannot but draw police attention.
The weird bit from Colnel Mustard just before the denouement about taking Elsie into town baffles me.
No comments:
Post a Comment