I ran across this list (via Use of Weapons, via an Iain Banks obit). So I thought I'd check. I've read 25, and disagree with the inclusion of 8.
Key:
* R - read (and if so, whether I agree it merits the list),
* N - not read.
Of the one's I've said "yes" to, almost all fit into the "an entirely new concept". Ender's game was for the video arcade generation, for example.
N The Handmaid’s Tale (1985) R Ender’s Game (1985) - yes. An entirely new concept N Radio Free Albemuth (1985) R Always Coming Home (1985) - no. Not without merit, but compared to Earthsea, its nothing. N This Is the Way the World Ends (1985) R Galápagos (1985) - no. Just a toy parable N The Falling Woman (1986) N The Shore of Women (1986) N A Door Into Ocean (1986) N Soldiers of Paradise (1987) N Life During Wartime (1987) - but the Talking Heads song is astounding R The Sea and Summer (1987) - yes. Elegaic N Cyteen (1988) N Neverness (1988) N The Steerswoman (1989) R Grass (1989) - yes. R Use of Weapons (1990) - yes. Classic Culture R Queen of Angels (1990) - yes. The excitement and ultimate disappointment of a probe to another star N Barrayar (1991) N Synners (1991) N Sarah Canary (1991) R White Queen (1991) - yes. Superb R Eternal Light (1991) - yes. Mysterious mind-expanding space opera R Stations of the Tide (1991) - yes. Pretty damn weird. Vacuum Flowers should also be on the list N Timelike Infinity (1992) N Dead Girls (1992) N Jumper (1992) N China Mountain Zhang (1992) R Red Mars (1992) - no. Overblown. Icehenge is KSR's classic R A Fire Upon the Deep (1992) - yes. R Aristoi (1992) - yes. N Doomsday Book (1992) N Parable of the Sower (1993) N Ammonite (1993) N Chimera (1993) R Nightside the Long Sun (1993) - no. Book of the New Sun is Wolfe's classic, as any Fule Kno N Brittle Innings (1994) N Permutation City (1994) N Blood (1994) N Mother of Storms (1995) R Sailing Bright Eternity (1995) - no, drivel. In the Ocean of Night is the classic (and I'll allow you Across the Sea of Suns) but its downhill from there N Galatea 2.2 (1995) R The Diamond Age (1995) - yes N The Transmigration of Souls (1996) N The Fortunate Fall (1996) N The Sparrow/Children of God (1996/1998) N Holy Fire (1996) R Night Lamp (1996) - yes. Its Jack Vance, not at his best, but even his worst is better than most people's best N In the Garden of Iden (1997) R Forever Peace (1997) - no. Read and marvel at The Forever War, and stop there N Glimmering (1997) N As She Climbed Across the Table (1997) R The Cassini Division (1998) - yes N Bloom (1998) R Vast (1998) - no. An attempt at weird / mysterious, but it doesn't work N The Golden Globe (1998) N Headlong (1999) N Cave of Stars (1999) N Genesis (2000) N Super-Cannes (2000) N Under the Skin (2000) N Perdido Street Station (2000) N Distance Haze (2000) R Revelation Space trilogy (2000) -yes R Salt (2000) - no. I *think* I've read this one. All his books are sort-of the same, and nearly-good-enough. Consider Snow instead N Ventus (2001) N The Cassandra Complex (2001) N Light (2002) R Altered Carbon (2002) - yes N The Separation (2002) N The Golden Age (2002) N The Time Traveler’s Wife (2003) N Natural History (2003) N The Labyrinth Key / Spears of God N River of Gods (2004) N The Plot Against America (2004) N Never Let Me Go (2005) N The House of Storms (2005) N Counting Heads (2005) N Air (Or, Have Not Have) (2005) N Accelerando (2005) N Spin (2005) N My Dirty Little Book of Stolen Time (2006) N The Road (2006) N Temeraire / His Majesty’s Dragon (2006) [2019 update: now read, and no: read Uprooted, or Spinning Silver] N Blindsight (2006) [2024 update: now read, not enthusiastic] N HARM (2007) N The Yiddish Policemen’s Union (2007) N The Secret City (2007) N In War Times (2007) N Postsingular (2007) N Shadow of the Scorpion (2008) R The Hunger Games trilogy (2008-2010) - maybe. I read book 1, and liked it, but declined the chance to read book 2 N Little Brother (2008) N The Alchemy of Stone (2008) R The Windup Girl (2009) - yes N Steal Across the Sky(2009) N Boneshaker (2009) N Zoo City (2010) N Zero History (2010) N The Quantum Thief (2010)
I'm not doing a good job reading the recent stuff, am I?
No comments:
Post a Comment